{"incident_date":"2020-05-30","received_date":"2020-05-31","close_date":"2022-04-21","borough":"Manhattan","precinct":28,"location_type":"Street/highway","contact_reason":"Demonstration/protest","contact_outcome":"No arrest made or summons issued","disposition":"Substantiated (Charges)","evidence_bwc":true,"evidence_video":true,"precinct_command_id":"28pct","allegations":[{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Nightstick as club (incl asp & baton)","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Officer(s) Unidentified","id":1095935},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Restricted Breathing","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Officer(s) Unidentified","id":1095936},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Chokehold","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Officer(s) Unidentified","id":1097866},{"fado_type":"Discourtesy","allegation":"Word","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1100308,"officer_id":"RXET"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Nightstick as club (incl asp & baton)","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Unsubstantiated","id":1103416,"officer_id":"D27"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Threat of force (verbal or physical)","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline B)","id":1103557,"officer_id":"RXET"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Female","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Exonerated","id":1104673,"officer_id":"XEYX"},{"fado_type":"Discourtesy","allegation":"Word","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Officer(s) Unidentified","id":1105577},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Exonerated","id":1105580,"officer_id":"XEYX"},{"fado_type":"Discourtesy","allegation":"Word","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Female","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Exonerated","id":1105581,"officer_id":"XEYX"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Female","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Exonerated","id":1105582,"officer_id":"XEYX"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline B)","id":1105584,"officer_id":"EEKD"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline B)","id":1105586,"officer_id":"EEKD"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Chokehold","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Charges)","id":1105587,"officer_id":"NDXK"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Nightstick as club (incl asp & baton)","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Exonerated","id":1105588,"officer_id":"NDXK"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Threat of force (verbal or physical)","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline B)","id":1169835,"officer_id":"EEKD"},{"fado_type":"Discourtesy","allegation":"Word","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1170295,"officer_id":"EEKD"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Nightstick as club (incl asp & baton)","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Unsubstantiated","id":1170297,"officer_id":"D27"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Sex Miscon (Sexual Harassment, Verbal)","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Charges)","id":1170342,"officer_id":"RXET"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Threat of force (verbal or physical)","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline B)","id":1170415,"officer_id":"NDXK"},{"fado_type":"Offensive Language","allegation":"Gender","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Charges)","id":1170416,"officer_id":"NDXK"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Threat of force (verbal or physical)","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Exonerated","id":1170428,"officer_id":"VSQF"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Threat of force (verbal or physical)","victim_gender":"Female","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline B)","id":1170462,"officer_id":"NDXK"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_gender":"Female","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline B)","id":1170463,"officer_id":"NDXK"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline B)","id":1170464,"officer_id":"NDXK"},{"fado_type":"Discourtesy","allegation":"Word","victim_gender":"Female","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1170466,"officer_id":"NDXK"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Nightstick as club (incl asp & baton)","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Exonerated","id":1170502,"officer_id":"NDXK"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Exonerated","id":1170503},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Threat of force (verbal or physical)","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Exonerated","id":1170504},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Exonerated","id":1170505,"officer_id":"VSQF"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Exonerated","id":1170506,"officer_id":"NDXK"},{"fado_type":"Discourtesy","allegation":"Word","victim_age_incident":"30-34","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1171098,"officer_id":"NDXK"},{"fado_type":"Discourtesy","allegation":"Action","victim_gender":"Female","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1171099,"officer_id":"NDXK"}],"penalties":[{"ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline B)","board_recommendation":"Substantiated (Charges)","apu_plea_penalty":"Formalized Training","apu_case_status":"Closed: Plea set aside, Without discipline","apu_closing_date":"2025-09-30","nypd_disposition":"APU Dismissed","officer_id":"EEKD"},{"ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Charges)","board_recommendation":"Substantiated (Charges)","apu_case_status":"Closed: Retained, without discipline","apu_closing_date":"2024-09-12","nypd_disposition":"APU Closed: Retained, without discipline","officer_id":"NDXK"},{"ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Charges)","board_recommendation":"Substantiated (Charges)","apu_case_status":"Closed: Charges not served","apu_closing_date":"2023-03-11","nypd_disposition":"APU Closed: Charges not served","officer_id":"RXET"}],"documents":[{"url":"https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/23816990-apureport2023-q1pdf#document/p11/a2383122","type":"apu-quarterly-report","officer_ids":["RXET"]},{"url":"https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/25345350-apureport2024q3pdf#document/p29/a2618139","type":"apu-quarterly-report","officer_ids":["NDXK"]},{"url":"https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/26206387-apureport2025q3pdf/#document/p7/a2806556","type":"apu-quarterly-report","officer_ids":["EEKD"]},{"url":"https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/26182808-202003791_redactedclosingreportpdf/","type":"closing-report"},{"url":"https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/25345420-202003791-tax965766-apu-final-documentspdf/","type":"retained-letter","officer_ids":["NDXK"]},{"url":"https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/26206397-202003791-tax950604-apu-final-documentspdf/","type":"plea-agreement","officer_ids":["EEKD"]}],"summary":"On May 30, 2020, at approximately 11:30 p.m., in front of [redacted] in Manhattan, Police Officer Marc Hummel used force against [redacted] (Allegations A and B: Force, [redacted]). At the intersection of West 114th Street and Frederick Douglas Boulevard in Manhattan, PO Hummel threatened [redacted] with the use of force (Allegation C: Abuse of Authority, [redacted]), and spoke discourteously to [redacted] (Allegation D: Discourtesy, [redacted]). Police Officer Sean Sloman struck [redacted] with a baton (Allegations E and F: Force, [redacted]). An officer struck [redacted] with a baton, placed [redacted] in a chokehold, and restricted [redacted]'s breathing (Allegations G through I: Force, [redacted]). An officer spoke discourteously to [redacted] (Allegation J: Discourtesy, [redacted]). Sergeant Francisco Garcia used physical force against [redacted] (Allegations K and L: Force, [redacted]), and spoke discourteously to her (Allegation M: Discourtesy, [redacted]). Police Officer Sokol Karaduzovic threatened [redacted] and individuals with the use of force (Allegations N and O: Abuse of Authority, [redacted]). PO Karaduzovic spoke discourteously to (Allegation P: Discourtesy, [redacted]), and made an offensive remark to [redacted] and individuals (Allegation Q: Offensive Language, [redacted]). PO Karaduzovic acted and spoke discourteously to [redacted] (Allegations R and S: Discourtesy, [redacted]). PO Karaduzovic used physical force against individuals and [redacted] (Allegations T and U: Force, [redacted]). PO Karaduzovic struck [redacted] with his baton, and used physical force against [redacted] (Allegations V through X: Force, [redacted]). Lieutenant Mervin Bennett used force against [redacted] (Allegation Y: Force, [redacted]). An officer threatened [redacted] with the use of force (Allegation Z: Abuse of Authority, [redacted]). Officers used force against [redacted] (Allegation AA: Force, [redacted]). PO Karaduzovic used a chokehold against [redacted] (Allegation AB: Force, [redacted]). Sgt. Garcia used...","witness_officers":[{"last_name":"Abramowitz","first_name":"Ian","officer_id":"PGPF"},{"last_name":"Ahmed","first_name":"Shahzeb","officer_id":"KD6P"},{"last_name":"Aly","first_name":"Ahmed","officer_id":"TWHK"},{"last_name":"Azzolino","first_name":"Daniel","officer_id":"K9QZ"},{"last_name":"Bernard","first_name":"Mark","officer_id":"4PM3"},{"last_name":"Bredwood","first_name":"Blair","officer_id":"T6KM"},{"last_name":"Bula","first_name":"Shane","officer_id":"TXKX"},{"last_name":"Carrero","first_name":"Juan","officer_id":"GESZ"},{"last_name":"Carvajal","first_name":"Luis","officer_id":"QW4K"},{"last_name":"Crawford","first_name":"Jenna","officer_id":"37VK"},{"last_name":"Cruz","first_name":"Rafael","officer_id":"VDKT"},{"last_name":"Czaplinski","first_name":"Robert","officer_id":"WLM7"},{"last_name":"Dement","first_name":"Andrew","officer_id":"TD5B"},{"last_name":"Diaz","first_name":"Larissa","officer_id":"45RT"},{"last_name":"Espinoza","first_name":"Marcelo","officer_id":"UYL7"},{"last_name":"Etienne","first_name":"Keph","officer_id":"5JDX"},{"last_name":"Garcia","first_name":"Caridad","officer_id":"8V2F"},{"last_name":"Garcia","first_name":"Rusty","officer_id":"PAZV"},{"last_name":"Giarro","first_name":"Frank","officer_id":"7XJD"},{"last_name":"Gibson","first_name":"Lamont","officer_id":"H5UT"},{"last_name":"Gordian","first_name":"Jose","officer_id":"CBCR"},{"last_name":"Grant","first_name":"Darrion","officer_id":"EQC7"},{"last_name":"Guevarra","first_name":"Joshua","officer_id":"A6MD"},{"last_name":"Hanna","first_name":"Stephanie","officer_id":"6KV7"},{"last_name":"Hartigan","first_name":"Justin","officer_id":"JFR5"},{"last_name":"Huda","first_name":"Syed","officer_id":"UW5F"},{"last_name":"Ilowite","first_name":"Alexa","officer_id":"VUET"},{"last_name":"Joachim","first_name":"Kingsley","officer_id":"QGTV"},{"last_name":"Kendall","first_name":"Keyana","officer_id":"96VF"},{"last_name":"Mancilla","first_name":"Walter","officer_id":"SB8X"},{"last_name":"Martin","first_name":"Jeffrey","officer_id":"4Q27"},{"last_name":"Mcguire","first_name":"Thomas","officer_id":"HUWX"},{"last_name":"Mcnulty","first_name":"Daniel","officer_id":"W22T"},{"last_name":"Monnelly","first_name":"Michael","officer_id":"N7B"},{"last_name":"Pacheco","first_name":"Jose","officer_id":"WFMT"},{"last_name":"Paulino","first_name":"Ajdina","officer_id":"A3EK"},{"last_name":"Pennacchia","first_name":"Johnpaul","officer_id":"HMVB"},{"last_name":"Ramirez","first_name":"Felipe","officer_id":"ALB7"},{"last_name":"Reilly","first_name":"Patrick","officer_id":"CBYF"},{"last_name":"Roark","first_name":"Nicole","officer_id":"CGG7"},{"last_name":"Rodriguez","first_name":"Geraldo","officer_id":"WSE7"},{"last_name":"Rosario","first_name":"Williams","officer_id":"P3YV"},{"last_name":"Saal","first_name":"Christian","officer_id":"NDQP"},{"last_name":"Sanchez","first_name":"Christian","officer_id":"QV8F"},{"last_name":"Testa","first_name":"Mark","officer_id":"DVKX"},{"last_name":"Thuesday","first_name":"Gregory","officer_id":"FQ2V"},{"last_name":"Torres","first_name":"Joel","officer_id":"7DGK"},{"last_name":"Wells","first_name":"Theodore","officer_id":"H6MT"},{"last_name":"Ye","first_name":"Thomas","officer_id":"WAVB"},{"last_name":"Zhao","first_name":"Karen","officer_id":"NLDT"}],"id":202003791,"updated_date":"2025-10-02T13:04:00.971Z","url":"https://www.50-a.org/complaint/202003791"}