{"incident_date":"2023-02-28","received_date":"2023-03-09","close_date":"2024-06-18","borough":"Manhattan","precinct":25,"location_type":"Subway station/train","contact_reason":"PD suspected C/V of violation/crime - subway","contact_outcome":"Summons - other violation/crime","disposition":"Substantiated (Charges)","evidence_bwc":true,"evidence_video":false,"precinct_command_id":"25pct","allegations":[{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Unfounded","id":1212846,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Threat of force (verbal or physical)","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Unable to Determine","id":1215519,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Threat of force (verbal or physical)","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Unable to Determine","id":1215520,"officer_id":"585T"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Handcuffs too tight","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Unable to Determine","id":1215521,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Threat of arrest","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Unfounded","id":1215523,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Threat of force (verbal or physical)","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Unfounded","id":1215524,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Threat of force (verbal or physical)","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Unfounded","id":1215525,"officer_id":"585T"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Unable to Determine","id":1215539,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Unable to Determine","id":1215540,"officer_id":"585T"},{"fado_type":"Discourtesy","allegation":"Word","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Within NYPD Guidelines","id":1215542,"officer_id":"585T"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Refusal to obtain medical treatment","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Unfounded","id":1215543,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Threat of arrest","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Within NYPD Guidelines","id":1252350,"officer_id":"585T"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Improper use of body-worn camera","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1252351,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Improper use of body-worn camera","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1252352,"officer_id":"585T"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Improper use of body-worn camera","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1252353,"officer_id":"PN73"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Improper use of body-worn camera","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1252354,"officer_id":"MQQT"},{"fado_type":"Discourtesy","allegation":"Word","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1253882,"officer_id":"585T"},{"fado_type":"Discourtesy","allegation":"Word","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1253884,"officer_id":"585T"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Unable to Determine","id":1253885,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Unable to Determine","id":1253886,"officer_id":"585T"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Search (of person)","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Within NYPD Guidelines","id":1253889,"officer_id":"MQQT"},{"fado_type":"Offensive Language","allegation":"Disability","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Charges)","id":1254244,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Discourtesy","allegation":"Word","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1254245,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Unable to Determine","id":1254246,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Search (of person)","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1256359,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Improper use of body-worn camera","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1256384,"officer_id":"VTJD"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Improper use of body-worn camera","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1256385,"officer_id":"QYRK"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Unfounded","id":1259907,"officer_id":"585T"},{"fado_type":"Discourtesy","allegation":"Word","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","id":1259918,"officer_id":"585T"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Threat of arrest","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Within NYPD Guidelines","id":1260068,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Force","allegation":"Physical force","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline B)","id":1261523,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Refusal to obtain medical treatment","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Unfounded","id":1261524,"officer_id":"585T"},{"fado_type":"Offensive Language","allegation":"Disability","victim_age_incident":"40-44","victim_gender":"Male","victim_ethnicity":"Black","ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Charges)","id":1269329,"officer_id":"585T"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Stop","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Unable to Determine","id":1269830,"officer_id":"7QQ9"},{"fado_type":"Abuse of Authority","allegation":"Stop","victim_age_incident":"25-29","victim_gender":"Male","ccrb_disposition":"Unable to Determine","id":1269831,"officer_id":"585T"}],"penalties":[{"ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","board_recommendation":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","nypd_penalty":"No penalty","nypd_disposition":"No Disciplinary Action-DUP","officer_id":"MQQT"},{"ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","board_recommendation":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","nypd_penalty":"No penalty","nypd_disposition":"No Disciplinary Action-DUP","officer_id":"VTJD"},{"ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","board_recommendation":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","nypd_penalty":"No penalty","nypd_disposition":"No Disciplinary Action-DUP","officer_id":"QYRK"},{"ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Charges)","board_recommendation":"Substantiated (Charges)","apu_plea_penalty":"Forfeit vacation 5 days","apu_case_status":"Closed: Resolved by plea","apu_closing_date":"2025-02-03","nypd_penalty":"Forfeit vacation 5 days / Command Discipline A","nypd_disposition":"APU Guilty","officer_id":"585T"},{"ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","board_recommendation":"Substantiated (Command Discipline A)","nypd_penalty":"No penalty","nypd_disposition":"No Disciplinary Action-DUP","officer_id":"PN73"},{"ccrb_disposition":"Substantiated (Charges)","board_recommendation":"Substantiated (Charges)","apu_plea_penalty":"Forfeit vacation 5 days","apu_case_status":"Closed: Resolved by plea","apu_closing_date":"2025-02-03","nypd_penalty":"Forfeit vacation 5 days / Command Discipline A","nypd_disposition":"APU Guilty","officer_id":"7QQ9"}],"documents":[{"url":"https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/25940000-apureport2025q1pdf/#document/p16/a2666935","type":"apu-quarterly-report","officer_ids":["585T"]},{"url":"https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/25940000-apureport2025q1pdf/#document/p16/a2666936","type":"apu-quarterly-report","officer_ids":["7QQ9"]},{"url":"https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/25897759-202302015_redactedclosingreportpdf/","type":"closing-report"},{"url":"https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/25940035-202302015-tax965401-apu-final-documentspdf/","type":"plea-agreement","officer_ids":["585T"]},{"url":"https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/25940036-202302015-tax970781-apu-final-documentspdf/","type":"plea-agreement","officer_ids":["7QQ9"]}],"summary":"On February 28, 2023, at approximately 9:00am, Police Officer Binah Previl and Police Officer Rafael Payano, both of Transit District 4 (PO Previl has since been transferred to Transit Bureau Response), observed [redacted] allegedly evade transit fare. PO Previl and PO Payano pursued [redacted] and commanded him to stop, but he continued past them. PO Payano grabbed him and pushed him, and PO Previl placed him in handcuffs (Allegation A and B: Abuse of Authority-Stop, [redacted] and (Allegation C and D: Force-Physical Force, [redacted]). PO Previl reached into [redacted] bag to retrieve his ID (Allegation E: Abuse of Authority-- Search (of person), [redacted]). PO Payano told [redacted] \"I don't want to hear that shit right now,\" (Allegation F: Discourtesy-Word, [redacted]). PO Previl and PO Payano ejected [redacted] from the subway station and PO Previl told him that if he returned, he would be arrested (Allegation G: Abuse of Authority-Threat of Arrest, [redacted]).\n\nAfter ejecting [redacted], PO Previl and PO Payano directed their attention to an unknown individual and [redacted]. Police Officer Jean Innocent and Police Officer Javier Romero, both of the Transit Bureau Anti-Terrorism Unit, as well as Police Officer Estrella Cespedes, of PSA 4, and Police Officer Luis Salvatierra, of PSA 8, joined PO Previl and PO Payano. PO Previl and PO Payano instructed the unknown individual and [redacted] to leave the subway station. When the unknown individual did not comply, PO Previl and PO Payano forced him out of the subway station (Allegations H and I: Force-Physical Force, [redacted]). PO Payano told the unknown individual, \"You're being fucking ejected\" (Allegations J: Discourtesy-Word, [redacted]). PO Payano told the unknown individual that if he returned to the subway station, he would be arrested (Allegation K: Abuse of Authority- Threat of Arrest, [redacted]).\n\nWhen PO Previl and PO Payano turned their attention to [redacted], they allegedly told him that they would harm him after they got off work...","witness_officers":[{"last_name":"Arsen","first_name":"Katrayen","officer_id":"EWDX"},{"last_name":"Buruca","first_name":"Marcos","officer_id":"WV5Z"},{"last_name":"Chowdhury","first_name":"Shamir","officer_id":"NMGH"},{"last_name":"Degennaro","first_name":"Vincent","officer_id":"6HJT"},{"last_name":"Marjanovic","first_name":"Monika","officer_id":"35JK"},{"last_name":"Ragone","first_name":"Nicholas","officer_id":"MHR"},{"last_name":"Sclafani","first_name":"Paul","officer_id":"N8V3"},{"last_name":"Yakal","first_name":"David","officer_id":"32BR"}],"id":202302015,"updated_date":"2025-02-05T06:31:18.811Z","url":"https://www.50-a.org/complaint/202302015"}