Complaint #202503678,
April 2, 2025

Officer: Aly, Moustafa
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Abuse of Authority: Threat of force (verbal or physical)
CCRB Conclusion: Within NYPD Guidelines
Officer: Aly, Moustafa
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Abuse of Authority: Search (of person)
CCRB Conclusion: Substantiated (Command Discipline A)
Officer: Aly, Moustafa
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Abuse of Authority: Seizure of property
CCRB Conclusion: Unable to Determine
Officer: Rodriguez, Xavier
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Abuse of Authority: Threat to damage/seize property
CCRB Investigator Recommendation: Substantiated
CCRB Board Conclusion: Within NYPD Guidelines
Officer: Aly, Moustafa
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Discourtesy: Word
CCRB Investigator Recommendation: Substantiated
CCRB Board Conclusion: Within NYPD Guidelines
Officer: Obrien, Melanie
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Abuse of Authority: Stop
CCRB Conclusion: Within NYPD Guidelines
Officer: Aly, Moustafa
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Abuse of Authority: Stop
CCRB Conclusion: Within NYPD Guidelines
Officer: Obrien, Melanie
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Abuse of Authority: Threat to damage/seize property
CCRB Investigator Recommendation: Substantiated
CCRB Board Conclusion: Within NYPD Guidelines
Officer: Rodriguez, Xavier
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Discourtesy: Word
CCRB Investigator Recommendation: Substantiated
CCRB Board Conclusion: Within NYPD Guidelines
Officer: Khan, Imran
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Abuse of Authority: Threat of arrest
CCRB Investigator Recommendation: Substantiated
CCRB Board Conclusion: Within NYPD Guidelines
Officer: Khan, Imran
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Abuse of Authority: Threat to damage/seize property
CCRB Investigator Recommendation: Substantiated
CCRB Board Conclusion: Within NYPD Guidelines
Officer: Aly, Moustafa
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Abuse of Authority: Unlawful Summons
CCRB Conclusion: Substantiated (Charges)
Officer: Aly, Moustafa
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Force: Physical force
CCRB Conclusion: Within NYPD Guidelines
Officer: Aly, Moustafa
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Abuse of Authority: Search (of person)
CCRB Conclusion: Within NYPD Guidelines
Officer: Obrien, Melanie
Complainant: Black Male, 35-39
Allegation: Force: Physical force
CCRB Conclusion: Within NYPD Guidelines
Officer Complainant Allegation CCRB Board Conclusion
Aly, Moustafa Black Male, 35-39 Abuse of Authority: Threat of force (verbal or physical) Within NYPD Guidelines
Aly, Moustafa Black Male, 35-39 Abuse of Authority: Search (of person) Substantiated (Command Discipline A)
Aly, Moustafa Black Male, 35-39 Abuse of Authority: Seizure of property Unable to Determine
Rodriguez, Xavier Black Male, 35-39 Abuse of Authority: Threat to damage/seize property Within NYPD Guidelines
CCRB Investigator Recommendation: Substantiated
Aly, Moustafa Black Male, 35-39 Discourtesy: Word Within NYPD Guidelines
CCRB Investigator Recommendation: Substantiated
Obrien, Melanie Black Male, 35-39 Abuse of Authority: Stop Within NYPD Guidelines
Aly, Moustafa Black Male, 35-39 Abuse of Authority: Stop Within NYPD Guidelines
Obrien, Melanie Black Male, 35-39 Abuse of Authority: Threat to damage/seize property Within NYPD Guidelines
CCRB Investigator Recommendation: Substantiated
Rodriguez, Xavier Black Male, 35-39 Discourtesy: Word Within NYPD Guidelines
CCRB Investigator Recommendation: Substantiated
Khan, Imran Black Male, 35-39 Abuse of Authority: Threat of arrest Within NYPD Guidelines
CCRB Investigator Recommendation: Substantiated
Khan, Imran Black Male, 35-39 Abuse of Authority: Threat to damage/seize property Within NYPD Guidelines
CCRB Investigator Recommendation: Substantiated
Aly, Moustafa Black Male, 35-39 Abuse of Authority: Unlawful Summons Substantiated (Charges)
Aly, Moustafa Black Male, 35-39 Force: Physical force Within NYPD Guidelines
Aly, Moustafa Black Male, 35-39 Abuse of Authority: Search (of person) Within NYPD Guidelines
Obrien, Melanie Black Male, 35-39 Force: Physical force Within NYPD Guidelines

Conclusion Meanings:

'Substantiated': The misconduct occurred and it violated the rules. The NYPD has discretion over what, if any, discipline is imposed.
'Unable to Determine': The alleged conduct was investigated but could not determine both that the conduct occurred and that it broke the rules.
'Within NYPD Guidelines': The conduct occurred but did not violate the NYPD's own rules, which often give officers significant discretion.

Further details on conclusions.


Penalty

Aly, Moustafa
Pending
APU - Decision Pending

Details

Incident: April 2, 2025
Received: April 14, 2025
Closed: August 18, 2026

Reason for contact: Report-dispute
Location: Street/highway
In NYPD 73rd Precinct Brooklyn
Outcome: Summons - disorderly conduct

Body-Worn Camera evidence collected